Looking for a board game to play with your pals the following night? Fear not, for we have created the finest mystery board games that money can buy.
We recognize how challenging it can be to select the top mystery board games, but fear not—we have already done the legwork for you.
In addition, even though mystery murder board games rule the market, we have listed several additional intriguing mystery games. Continue reading because you’ll find some fascinating ones there.
The Top 10 Board Games of Mystery
My Best’s analysis serves as the foundation for our ranking. Similar to how not everyone will agree with our ranking, you should pick the one you think is best.
So, here’s a brief peek at today’s ranking.
| Rank | Name of the Board Game | Price |
| 10 | Suspicion | $19.99 |
| 9 | Clue Retro Series 1986 | $19.99 |
| 8 | The Resistance | $18.60 |
| 7 | Death at the Dive Bar | $29.99 |
| 6 | Exit: The Sinister Mansion | $13.70 |
| 5 | 221B Baker Street | $47.51 |
| 4 | Mysterium | $43.97 |
| 3 | Salem | $24.99 |
| 2 | Deception: Murder in Hong Kong | $31.65 |
| 1 | Betrayal at the House on the Hill | $29.49 |
10. Suspicion
Do you enjoy playing mystery games but find spooky tales about crimes or murder to be unappealing? You’ll like this one if that’s the case.
In terms of the game, it is about an opulent art collector’s masquerade party. The guests at the party do, however, include a jewel thief. The gamers will therefore need to use their detective abilities to identify the culprit.
The game is thrilling, but several reviewers claimed that it was monotonous or too easy. Other critics, on the other hand, commended the game’s narrative and simplicity.
It is an enjoyable game for families with children to play, and even children who are younger than the required age can do so, claim the reviewers.
9. The 1986 edition of Clue
Our list would be lacking without mentioning the most well-known and one of the best mystery board games.
Aside from that, let’s not overlook the 35 years of success this game has enjoyed. Kids can easily play without much difficulty because the characters have recognizable names.
As Colonel Mustard or Mrs. Peacock, we have to name the weapon, the chamber, and the perpetrator in the game.
You desire more board games. The 5 Best Zombie Board Games for Unlimited Fun are described in more detail here.
8. The Opposition
The Resistance is at position eight. One of the top board games with a mystery theme that you can purchase at a decent price is this one. You have the option of playing as a spy or a resistance fighter in this game.
Missions to overthrow the government will need to be completed by the resistance, and spies will use every trick in the book to stop them. But no one is aware of the identity of the spy or rebel.
One of this game’s best features is that, due to its size, you can easily transport it to the party if you’re the one who brings it.
The game’s mechanics mainly rely on players conversing, and some critics have expressed concern that players who play silently may grow confused. It was enjoyable, contrary to what the other reviewers said.
7. The Dive Bar’s Fatal Accident
That this game made the list of the top mystery board games wasn’t a surprise. In terms of the game itself, the creators of the well-known murder mystery subscription box created Hunt a Killer as a mystery board game.
This game uses actual things, as opposed to other ones that rely on cards and boards, to give you a more realistic sense of being a real detective.
After figuring out the riddle, you are sadly unable to access the game. However, it’s wonderful for special occasions!
Moving on to the detractors, some say they were disappointed in the amount of reading necessary because it led to less discussion.
This article, The 5 Best Cooperative Board Games for Family Fun, might be of interest. To learn more, click here.
6. Leave through The Evil Mansion
Exit, in contrast to other board games, can be played by one player or up to four players simultaneously. Exit stands out from other companies because of this.
Here, players go to a frightening house to solve a mystery but wind up stuck inside it instead. To escape before the time limit expires, they must solve puzzles and find hints.
You can only play it once since to find the solution, we must destroy some elements.
The puzzles are allegedly overly difficult, according to several critics. Other reviewers, though, were fascinated by the game’s story and thrill.
5.5 Baker Street
When it comes to preventing the players from being too competitive, this game is the greatest option. To solve the case, a series of clues must be used to explore a riddle that is supplied to the players.
You can play the game alone or in groups as well. There are 200 riddles, so expect a lot of repetitions
However, some reviews complained that certain elements of the game were lacking. The other critics, though, claimed the guidelines were too straightforward. Similar to this, positive reviews praise the game’s straightforwardness and simplicity.
4. Suspicions
If you want to avoid competition but still have a big group of friends to play with on the weekends, Mysterium is an excellent option.
In the game, which brings up characters, they are all mediums or spirits who must cooperate to look into a crime at Warwick Manor.
The game also changes every time depending on the players. However, the game has been advertised for two to seven players; four or more players must abide by the regular rules. In addition, special limitations are included in the two-player and three-player modes.
But reports claim that setting up the game requires a lot of space and time. Positive reviews, on the other hand, highlight the game’s stunning graphics and premium materials.
3. Salem
This game is for you if you enjoy fantasy, magic, and witch-type activities more. Salem, one of the best board games with a mystery, is a witch hunt where the witch may be any of your pals.
The majority of the players in this game are regular citizens, but there are still witches lurking among them who will try to kill or convert the other players to win. This game will make you distrust everyone.
But the rules are harder to understand, according to the detractors. But most people agreed that it’s quite addictive once you get the hang of it.
Even the friendliest among you could become vicious liars for 45 minutes under its influence.
Check out the 12 Best Deduction Board Games, too.
2. Fraud: A murder in Hong Kong
Moving on to the second board game, Deception is a lovely substitute if you prefer a game with a shorter playing time. With a murderer and a forensic scientist, the goal of the game is to identify the offender and the tool used to carry out the crime.
Each game lasts about 20 minutes, requires 250 cards to play, and is simple and enjoyable to play.
Now, about the reviewers, they argued that the game was too simple and not very enjoyable when played by a small number of people. They suggested that the game would be more enjoyable if there were six or more players.
1. Betrayal at the Hill House
For the finest board game with a mystery, we offer Betrayal at the House on the Hill. This is a well-liked game that keeps gamers coming back for more.
Players try to find more rooms in this area so they can leave the cursed mansion on the hill. One of the participants can turn traitor at any moment. When a traitor is exposed, a story is revealed.
The team must come together to defeat the traitor as they attempt to use their abilities to attack the entire squad.
Many players appear to find the game’s numerous regulations to be irritating. Others have noted that the subject is somewhat depressing, which can frighten many people because most of them claimed that they had to read them multiple times to understand it.
Others, however, appreciated the game’s strong storyline and replayability. Compared to other mystery board games, this one has received a lot of positive reviews.
Conclusion
There are numerous game options with never-ending tales and secrets concealed within them. Each with a distinct storyline and a distinctive twist. Therefore, it is up to us to pick the ideal candidate. Because it is our money, why not be a little fussy with it?
What was your favorite game out of all the excellent ones mentioned above? Furthermore, why did you prefer it above the other options available? Let us know at any time.
Also Read: Antje Utgaard, Yasmin Vossoughian, Ahna O’Reilly